The Government has been advised, including by the Government Actuary, of a number of concerns with the provision of defined benefit pensions in small superannuation funds, namely:
- access to unintended tax and social security benefits, particularly from the use of ‘RBL compression’;
- their use for estate planning purposes in the superannuation system outside what was intended and not available to other superannuation fund members; and
- whether a small number of members can effectively pool risk and guarantee income payments over the term of the pension.
The Government has established a team to address these concerns and review the provision of pensions in small superannuation funds.
The review will examine options for small superannuation funds to provide pensions to their members, including consideration of:
- design features of prospective pensions that address the Government’s concerns and that could attract complying status for taxation and social security purposes;
- management of investment, liquidity and mortality risks; and
- likely future demand for pensions with defined benefit characteristics.
The review will be conducted by a team within the Department of Treasury, including a representative from the Australian Government Actuary’s Office, and will consult with industry and other stakeholders, superannuation regulators and the Department of Family and Community Services.
An initial round of consultation will aid Treasury in developing a discussion paper. The Treasury discussion paper will outline key issues and canvass options and is expected to be released by the end of the year [2004]. Following further consultation, Treasury will report to Government by April 2005.
This consultation forms part of the Review of the Provision of Pensions in Small Superannuation Funds.
Submissions
29 submissions were received for this consultation.
- Actuarial Solutions Pty Ltd - pdf 138.16 KB
- Association of Independent Retirees (AIR) Limited — Whyalla and Districts Branch - pdf 323.24 KB
- Association of Superannuation Funds of Australia Ltd - pdf 890.59 KB
- Bray, Ross - pdf 621.09 KB
- c2004-pop-tor-028_Smartsuper_Pty_Ltd - pdf 55.3 KB
- CPA Australia - pdf 33.63 KB
- Dobson, Lyne - pdf 390.91 KB
- Ellis, Edward - pdf 8.73 KB
- Financial Planning Association of Australia Ltd - pdf 240.73 KB
- Frank Phillips & Associates - pdf 17.63 KB
- Heffron Consulting Pty Ltd - pdf 178.13 KB
- Institute of Actuaries of Australia (executive summary) - pdf 62.06 KB
- Institute of Actuaries of Australia (submission) - pdf 156.02 KB
- Institute of Chartered Accountants in Australia - pdf 170.56 KB
- Investment & Financial Services Association Ltd - pdf 49.74 KB
- Jacobs, Richard - pdf 62.12 KB
- Korman, Dr Ben - pdf 681.2 KB
- Lethbridge, David - pdf 21.23 KB
- McIntosh Financial Planning Pty Ltd - pdf 47.54 KB
- McKenzie Financial Advisers - pdf 1.69 MB
- PricewaterhouseCoopers Securities Ltd - pdf 4.8 MB
- Rice Walker Actuaries Pty Ltd (retirement incomes integration paper) - pdf 542.25 KB
- Rice Walker Actuaries Pty Ltd (submission) - pdf 263.25 KB
- SAIPrivate - pdf 2.13 MB
- Small Independent Superannuation Funds Association - pdf 42.77 KB
- SMSF Advisory Services Pty Ltd - pdf 307.2 KB
- Taxation Institute of Australia - pdf 2.21 MB
- Taxpayers Australia Inc - pdf 88.78 KB
- Tindale, Mark - pdf 26.46 KB